SAT vs the ACT® test
SAT vs the ACT test: What’s Changing in 2025 and What It Means for Students
Now that summer’s well underway, it’s time for rising juniors and seniors to take a serious look at preparing for standardized tests. But before students put their noses to the grindstone, there’s an important question to answer: which test?
Science and Section Weighting
The SAT and the ACT test have three sections in common — math, reading, and grammar (which the ACT test calls English, and the SAT calls Writing and Language). But the ACT test also has a fourth section: science. This section tests students’ ability to interpret data and understand the scientific method, not science content. While the SAT has tried to incorporate similar skills through scattered data interpretation questions in its math and reading sections, it hasn’t included a standalone science portion.
Starting in April 2025 for online testers and in September 2025 for all formats, the ACT test is undergoing a major update. The science section will become optional, and the ACT test scores will be based on just three core sections: English, math, and reading. Students who choose to take the science section will receive a separate science score, and those who take both science and math will also get a STEM score.
So what does this mean in practice? While the SAT weighs math at 50% and reading/grammar at roughly 25% each, the ACT test used to weigh all four sections equally at 25%. But now, the ACT test will shift to weighting math, reading, and grammar more heavily—bringing it closer to the SAT’s breakdown, with added flexibility for those who still want to showcase science reasoning.
That said, even when it was required, the ACT test’s science section functioned more like a reading comprehension test, just with charts and graphs. In my experience teaching the ACT test, I’ve seen a much stronger correlation between reading and science scores than between science and math. If a student preparing for the SAT is doing relatively poorly in math, they might want to give the ACT test serious consideration, and vice versa.
Timing and Passages vs. Paragraphs
Another major difference between the tests is how they use their time limits.
The SAT gives students about two-thirds more time per question, which sounds like a good thing—until you realize that this means the SAT has room to make trickier, more complex questions.
In contrast, the ACT test has traditionally featured slightly more straightforward questions, but it has used its time limits as a meaningful constraint. The test was designed to give students barely enough time, and that remains true, although the upcoming changes will ease that pressure slightly. The ACT test will be shortened overall, with fewer questions and shorter reading passages, giving students more time per question. Still, it remains a fast-paced exam, especially in the reading and science sections, where it’s easy to get bogged down sifting through graphs, tables, or lengthy details. This can be uncomfortable for students used to finishing school tests with plenty of time to spare.
The SAT, on the other hand, has moved away from long reading passages in favor of individual paragraphs for each question. So, while individual questions may be trickier, students generally won’t get stuck on a particularly tough passage and run out of time.
It’s Okay to Switch!
Besides the science section and the timing differences, the fundamental content on both tests is very similar. There are differences — the SAT moving away from passages means that they can’t test students’ ability to recall or search for details, for instance. But any studying test-takers do on content and problem-solving for the math and grammar should carry over nicely. That means that if students find themselves in a rut preparing for one test, they should seriously consider the other without worrying about having wasted their time — sometimes the grass is greener!
Teachability and Logistics
One final consideration is the extent to which each test is “teachable.” Just this past year, the College Board redesigned the SAT’s entire format as part of its move to digital testing, after already having revamped it last decade in response to the growing popularity of the ACT test. That means practice materials for the SAT can be somewhat sparse and speculative, especially for students hoping to prepare with full-length tests.
By contrast, the ACT test remains highly consistent and predictable. There’s a vast supply of real exams for students to use in practice. The upcoming changes are designed to make the ACT test even more approachable: fewer questions, more time per question, and the flexibility to skip the science section if desired. These qualities make the ACT test particularly teachable, especially for students aiming to improve their scores significantly.
If you’re leaning toward the SAT and want help deciding how to study, check out our recent post on how to choose the best SAT test prep for your goals. It breaks down the pros and cons of tutoring, online classes, and free resources so you can build a study plan that works.
With all that said, many students don’t always get to choose. Some high schools offer free testing to students in the fall or spring, and with test center space becoming more limited, those school-provided dates might be a student’s only opportunity to test.
And that’s okay. While there are meaningful differences between the two tests, the test a student takes is far less important than the effort they put into preparing for it. Focus on building skills, reviewing key content, and practicing under real test conditions—those habits will make the biggest difference, no matter which test you take.